Submitted by Art Williams on Wed, 06/01/2011 - 11:34am
Vince,
Make sure you've allowed Anonymous posters to leave contact info. Also make sure you are viewing the comment form while logged out. It looks difference when a user is logged in.
Find the setting here:
Administration » Structure » Content types » (Your content type) » Comment Settings » Anonymous commenting » Anonymous posters (may not/may/must) leave their contact info.
